Blogger vs pLog
School still trying to figure out which blog is best to be deployed for use by staff, so I did a simple comparison between Google.com’s Blogger and the open-source pLog
Blogger | pLog | |
Cost | Software and hosting are free | Only Software is free – must use our own webserver (can be the same one used by school website). |
Interface | Colourful and very simple to use | Plain but also uncluttered and straightforward to use. |
Speed | Must regenerate pages every time user publishes – will get VERY SLOW over time. Server is based overseas so loading can take a long time. | Dynamic publishing – posts appear without need to regenerate blog. Optimised for Speed. Can be installed on a local server (in own country) so loads very quickly compared to an overseas site. |
Reliability | Experiences downtimes with heavy user traffic (especially as it is a free service used by many around the world). Could be down for a long time – must wait. | As reliable as our web host. In case of server problems, help is but a phone call away |
Attachments | Uploads are possible | Uploads are possible. Option to organise files into “albumsâ€. |
Pictures | As with attachments. | As with attachments. |
Search | No search function available. | Viewers can search entire blog for particular keywords. |
WYSIWYG editor | Available | Available |
Templates | Available | Available and can be pre-installed for all users. |
Links manager | Not available | Available. Links can also be sorted by pre-defined categories. |
Post categories | Not available. | Viewers can view posts organised by Categories e.g. Subject1, Subject2, etc |
Archives | Available | Simple archiving available |
Summary page | Not available. Must manually create a list of user blogs. | Only a single installation for as many users as needed. A “summary†page with listing of all user blogs automatically generated, with latest posts etc. Can act as a “blog portal†– a single URL for viewers to remember. |
Looks like pLog has just about everything in its favour. The only thing I have reservations about though is the user interface. While (especially in the just-released version 1.0) the UI is clean looking, alas it still isn’t as user-friendly to a newbie blogger as Blogger’s is. This is really important for teachers, who already have so little time for social life 🙁 that they really can’t afford the time to have to figure out what certain checkboxes mean.
Where UI in an open-source blogging software is concerned, my top choice is still DotClear. Alas, it lacks the many features of pLog. I’ll just have to wait and see how it goes…